Review

Film Reviews

The Feminine Rage in Netflix’s Big Hit: The Lizzie Borden Story

ByClarissa Dionisio@clarissa_jd

Netflix’s Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story is the fourth installment of Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan’s true-crime anthology series and the first to center on a female killer. Ella Beatty delivers a breakthrough performance as Lizzie, portraying her as a disillusioned visionary constrained by her strict Victorian upbringing.

Based on the real-life case of an unsolved murder, the creators explore repression and female rage through their female protagonist. However, this interpretation reflects my understanding of the season’s central themes. Murphy and Brennan aim to examine gender-based frustrations across two distinct historical periods. Interestingly, this season takes greater historical liberties than its predecessors. The axe used to murder Lizzie’s wealthy father and allegedly abusive stepmother becomes a symbol of the burdens imposed on women, including sexual violence, domestic abuse, financial dependence, sex work, household responsibilities, and childbirth.

Rather than focusing solely on the accused killer, the series examines the societal constraints imposed on women. As co-showrunner Brennan explains, “the job of the show was throwing into contrast this cage that any woman living in that time and place would’ve felt–but particularly, this strange young girl who loved animals and lived in a repressive household.”

Ultimately, the series explores feminine rage, gender roles, and the influence of gender on the perception of crime.

The series draws parallels between Lizzie and Aileen Wuornos, a notorious female serial killer who murdered seven men between 1989 and 1990, examining their respective characteristics and criminal cases. This comparison raises an intriguing question: why did people in the past struggle to believe that Lizzie could have committed a murder, while Aileen was convicted of similar crimes a century later? In an interview with PEOPLE, Brennan explains that “the contrast becomes clearer…what is the Lizzie of our world? How is she treated? And how does she lash out?”

The series also examines queer relationships and society’s treatment of them across two historical periods: the Victorian era and the 1990s, when Aileen’s girlfriend, Shelby, appears in the story. Shelby is based on her real-life partner, Tyria Moore, and is played by Jessica Lee. Similarly, the series depicts Lizzie pursuing a romantic relationship with the family maid, Maggie. Although no historical evidence confirms that they were romantically involved, speculation about Lizzie’s attraction to women has persisted.

Although the narrative departs from historical accuracy, these queer relationships serve as catalysts for rebellion and self-discovery. In an interview with Capital UK, Ella Beatty explains that Lizzie’s romantic relationship broadens her understanding of both the world and herself, symbolizing her liberation from restrictive social expectations.

The series adopts a theatrical, gothic-horror aesthetic that reinforces its central theme of a “feminine fantasy.” Despite the striking cinematography depicting Victorian-era Massachusetts, it is essential to consider how editing, lighting, dialogue, and other cinematic techniques communicate feminine rage. Through this visually compelling approach, Murphy and Brennan revisit a notorious murder case while addressing the enduring taboos surrounding gender, repression, and emotional expression in both the Victorian era and the present day.

Sources & Notes

Allen, Kelly. “What’s Fact and What’s Fiction in Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story?” People.Com, PEOPLE, 19 Sept. 2026, https://people.com/monster-the-lizzie-borden-story-fact-vs-fiction-12127514. Accessed 26 Oct. 2026. Prance, Sam. “Was Lizzie Borden Gay? The Truth Behind Her Lesbian Relationship in Monster Explained.” Capital, 21 Sept. 2026, https://www.capitalfm.com/news/tv-film/lizzie-borden-gay-lesbian-bridget-monster/. Accessed 26 Oct. 2026.

AI checked spelling and grammar.