Chapter 16: The Medical Examiner's Findings
Chapter 16 examines the medical examiner's role in the case. The autopsy may establish how Daniel Akers died, but the courtroom battle is over what those findings can actually prove about the person responsible.
Chapter 16: The Medical Examiner's Findings
What the Autopsy Can—and Cannot—Tell the Jury
Daniel Akers could no longer tell the jury what happened during his final moments.
He could not explain why he was in the basement.
He could not describe the confrontation with his wife.
He could not confirm whether he was holding the gun, whether a struggle occurred, or whether the fatal shot was intentional.
That left the medical evidence.
An autopsy can reveal important information about a person's death. It can document injuries, establish the cause of death, and help determine whether the death was accidental, suicidal, or the result of another person's actions.
But even the most detailed medical examination cannot answer every question.
In the trial of Lacy Jolee Boles, that distinction could become crucial.
THE AUTOPSY CONCLUSION
According to the reported case history, the medical examiner concluded that Daniel's fatal gunshot wound was not self-inflicted.
The death was classified as a homicide.
That finding became an important part of the investigation.
The Paulding County Sheriff's Office reportedly received the autopsy findings in May 2020. Boles was arrested on May 29, 2020.
But the word homicide has a specific meaning in death investigations.
It describes a death caused by another person.
It does not automatically establish murder under criminal law.
It does not identify the shooter.
And it does not establish that the shooting was intentional rather than accidental.
Those questions must be answered through the criminal investigation and the evidence presented at trial.
THE FATAL WOUND
During opening statements, prosecutor Jason Treadaway described the bullet entering Daniel's left nostril and traveling into his brain.
The description was graphic, but the medical significance was important.
The prosecution wanted jurors to understand the nature of the injury and the circumstances surrounding Daniel's death.
The defense, however, could examine whether the medical findings established the precise circumstances of the shooting.
A medical examiner might be asked to explain:
The location of the entrance wound.
The direction of the bullet's path.
The extent of the internal injuries.
Whether the findings were consistent with the reported circumstances.
What conclusions could reliably be drawn from the examination.
The answers could help jurors understand the physical consequences of the shooting.
But the bullet's path would not necessarily reveal every movement made by Daniel or Boles during the encounter.
THE QUESTION OF DISTANCE
One important issue in firearm investigations can be the distance between the weapon and the victim.
Depending on the condition of the evidence, medical and forensic examinations may reveal findings that help estimate whether a weapon was fired at close range or from farther away.
However, no specific firing-distance conclusion should be attributed to this case without verified testimony or forensic documentation.
If such evidence were introduced, both attorneys would have an opportunity to examine the methods used and the conclusions reached.
The prosecution might argue that the findings supported its reconstruction.
The defense might question whether those findings could distinguish an intentional shooting from an accidental discharge during a struggle.
The jury would need to understand both the scientific findings and their limitations.
COULD THE AUTOPSY DISPROVE THE DEFENSE?
The defense described Daniel as holding the gun near his mouth before Boles allegedly attempted to stop him.
That explanation raised a difficult question:
Could the medical evidence establish that the fatal shot occurred in a manner inconsistent with the defense's account?
The prosecution would want jurors to consider whether the medical findings contradicted the defense theory.
The defense would want to establish whether the findings actually ruled out its explanation.
There is a difference between evidence that makes an explanation less likely and evidence that makes it impossible.
A medical examiner must be able to explain that difference.
The jury should not be asked to treat scientific conclusions as more certain than they really are.
THE MEDICAL EXAMINER'S ROLE
The medical examiner is not supposed to decide whether the accused person is guilty.
That is the jury's responsibility.
The examiner's role is to explain the medical findings, describe the injuries, and provide professional opinions within the limits of the examination.
Attorneys may question the examiner about the methods used, the conclusions reached, and any uncertainty.
The defense may also explore whether other interpretations remain medically possible.
That does not mean the examiner's conclusions are automatically unreliable.
It means expert testimony must be examined like every other form of evidence.
WHAT THE AUTOPSY CANNOT TELL US
There were several questions the autopsy alone could not answer:
Did Boles intend to kill Daniel?
That is a question of criminal intent, not simply medical cause of death.
Was there a struggle?
The medical examination might provide relevant information, but a complete answer could require scene evidence, forensic findings, and witness testimony.
Was the gun deliberately fired?
The medical findings might help evaluate the circumstances, but they would not necessarily establish the shooter's state of mind.
Was the prosecution's timeline correct?
The autopsy could help establish medical facts, but the timeline would need to be supported by other evidence.
These distinctions were essential.
A homicide finding could establish that Daniel died because of another person's actions.
It could not, by itself, establish that Lacy Boles committed murder.
THE DEFENSE'S OPPORTUNITY
If the medical examiner testified, defense attorney Brian Steel would have an opportunity to examine the findings and challenge any conclusions that went beyond the available evidence.
He could explore whether the medical evidence supported the prosecution's theory, whether it contradicted the defense's account, or whether certain questions remained unanswered.
The prosecution would have an opportunity to clarify the medical findings and explain how they supported its case.
For jurors, the challenge would be separating scientific fact from courtroom interpretation.
THE QUESTION THAT REMAINS
The autopsy could tell the jury that Daniel Akers suffered a fatal gunshot wound.
It could explain the injury.
It could establish the medical examiner's conclusion about the manner of death.
But it could not independently reconstruct every second of the basement confrontation.
The prosecution still had to establish that Boles committed the charged crimes.
The defense still had the opportunity to challenge the state's interpretation.
And the jury still had to decide what the totality of the evidence proved.
The medical examiner might be able to explain how Daniel died.
But the courtroom still needed to answer the question that mattered most:
Was his death the result of an intentional act—or an accident during a desperate attempt to stop him?
That question would follow every witness who entered the courtroom.
END OF CHAPTER 16
Next: Chapter 17 — The Ballistics Evidence: Can the Gun Reveal Who Fired the Fatal Shot?
This chapter discusses the medical issues raised by the reported opening statements. It does not attribute unreported autopsy testimony or specific forensic conclusions to the medical examiner.
Chapter 17 turns to the firearm itself. The prosecution and defense may agree on the weapon involved, but they disagree sharply about how it was fired and what happened immediately before the fatal shot.
Chapter 17: The Ballistics Evidence
Can the Gun Reveal Who Fired the Fatal Shot?
A single gunshot ended Daniel Akers's life.
But the most important questions surrounding that shot remained unanswered.
Who was holding the firearm?
Was it pointed at Daniel deliberately?
Did Boles pull the trigger?
Or did the gun discharge accidentally when she allegedly tried to stop her husband from shooting himself?
The prosecution had its theory.
The defense had another.
And somewhere between those two competing accounts was a firearm that could potentially provide important answers.
THE .22-CALIBER PISTOL
During opening statements, jurors heard that a .22-caliber pistol was involved in Daniel's death.
The prosecution alleged that Boles used the weapon to shoot him in the face.
The defense described a very different sequence.
According to attorney Brian Steel, Daniel was holding the firearm in his left hand and pointing it toward his mouth when Boles encountered him in the basement.
She allegedly lunged to stop him.
During the struggle, the gun discharged.
The difference between these accounts was not merely about who touched the gun.
It was about intent.
The prosecution needed to establish criminal responsibility.
The defense wanted jurors to consider whether the shooting could have been accidental.
WHAT BALLISTICS CAN ESTABLISH
Firearms examination can provide important information.
Depending on the condition of the weapon and the available evidence, an examiner may be able to determine:
Whether a particular cartridge or bullet was fired from a specific firearm.
Whether the firearm was mechanically capable of firing.
Whether the weapon had any relevant mechanical defects.
Whether cartridge cases or other ballistic evidence are consistent with the firearm.
Whether the physical evidence supports or contradicts aspects of a proposed shooting sequence.
But there are limitations.
A firearms examiner generally cannot determine a person's thoughts.
The gun cannot reveal whether someone intended to kill.
And a mechanical examination alone cannot necessarily establish who pulled the trigger.
Those questions require the jury to consider the firearm evidence alongside the other evidence.
THE LEFT-HAND AND RIGHT-HAND DISPUTE
One of the most interesting details introduced during opening statements involved the position of the firearm.
The defense said Daniel was holding the gun in his left hand.
The prosecution emphasized that the weapon was found near his right hand.
That difference could become important, but it requires careful examination.
A firearm's final position does not necessarily establish its position at the exact moment it discharged.
The jury would need to hear how the scene was documented, whether the weapon was moved, and what investigators could reliably determine.
The defense could argue that the final position did not disprove its account.
The prosecution could argue that the evidence was inconsistent with the defense's description.
Neither interpretation should be accepted without examining the supporting evidence.
COULD THE GUN HAVE FIRED ACCIDENTALLY?
The defense's theory depended on the possibility that the firearm discharged during a struggle.
That raised several technical questions.
Was the firearm functioning normally?
Was there evidence of a mechanical malfunction?
Could its operation help explain how the shooting occurred?
Were there any findings that could establish whether the trigger was deliberately activated?
A firearms expert might be able to explain the weapon's mechanical characteristics.
However, even an examination showing that a firearm was functioning normally would not automatically prove that the shooting was intentional.
A functioning gun can still discharge accidentally.
The surrounding circumstances would matter.
THE MISSING PIECE: WHO WAS HOLDING IT?
The central question remained whether investigators could establish who had control of the firearm immediately before the shot.
Potentially relevant evidence could include fingerprints, DNA, trace evidence, photographs, and the physical condition of the scene.
But each type of evidence has limitations.
For example, fingerprints on a firearm might establish that someone handled it at some point. They would not necessarily establish who held it at the moment of discharge.
Likewise, the absence of a particular forensic finding would not automatically prove that someone never touched the weapon.
The jury would need to hear what evidence was actually collected, what testing was performed, and what conclusions could reasonably be drawn.
No specific fingerprint, DNA, or firearms-testing result should be assumed unless it is introduced through the trial evidence.
THE PROSECUTION'S INTERPRETATION
The state wanted jurors to see the firearm as part of a deliberate sequence.
According to the prosecution's opening statement:
1. Boles allegedly anticipated Daniel's return.
2. She allegedly positioned the Swiffer mop as an alert.
3. Daniel returned home.
4. Boles allegedly followed him into the basement.
5. She shot him with the pistol.
The prosecution's challenge was to connect those allegations to evidence that established intent and criminal responsibility.
The firearm could become one part of that connection.
But it could not tell the entire story by itself.
THE DEFENSE'S INTERPRETATION
The defense wanted jurors to consider a different sequence.
Daniel returned after allegedly being told not to come back.
Boles found him in the basement holding a gun.
He allegedly made a disturbing statement.
She lunged toward him.
The firearm discharged.
The defense's challenge was to show that this explanation was consistent with the physical evidence and raised reasonable doubt about the prosecution's theory.
The jury would not have to prove that the defense account was true.
It would have to determine whether the prosecution had eliminated reasonable doubt about the charged offenses.
THE WEAPON IS NOT THE WHOLE CASE
It would be easy to assume that the gun would provide the final answer.
But firearms evidence rarely exists in isolation.
The prosecution's theory also involved the mop, the couple's relationship, Daniel's movements, the reported statements, and the circumstances surrounding the shooting.
The defense's account involved the alleged confrontation, Daniel's reported state of mind, and the struggle over the firearm.
Each piece of evidence would need to be evaluated in context.
A gun can establish that a shot was fired.
It may provide clues about how the weapon functioned.
It cannot independently establish every action or intention of the people involved.
THE QUESTION THE JURY MUST ANSWER
The firearm was central to the case.
But the question was not simply whether it fired.
It was whether the prosecution could prove that Boles intentionally and unlawfully caused Daniel's death.
The state alleged that the shooting was deliberate.
The defense said it was accidental.
The jury would eventually have to decide which explanation was supported by the evidence beyond a reasonable doubt.
And another piece of the investigation could become just as important as the gun itself:
The crime scene.
Where was Daniel found?
What did investigators document?
What was moved?
And could the basement provide clues that neither side had fully explained?
The next chapter examines the scene where Daniel Akers died—and the questions surrounding its reconstruction.
END OF CHAPTER 17
Next: Chapter 18 — Inside the Basement: Reconstructing the Final Moments.
Accuracy note: This chapter explores the forensic questions raised by the two opening-statement theories. It does not claim that particular ballistics, fingerprint, DNA, or firearm-functioning results have been reported as trial evidence.
Sources & Notes
AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.