Chapter 24: The Crime Scene Evidence — The Bloody Handprint
The basement was no longer simply the place where Daniel Akers died.
It had become the center of a battle between two very different explanations.
According to the prosecution, the scene contained clues that contradicted Lacy Jolee Boles’s account of an accidental shooting during an attempt to stop her husband from taking his own life.
According to the defense, the evidence had not been properly investigated, preserved, or interpreted—and some of the most important questions remained unanswered.
Now the jury was being asked to examine the details.
And one ordinary object was attracting extraordinary attention.
A McDonald’s bag.
1. The Bag Beside Daniel
When investigators examined the basement, they noticed a McDonald’s bag near Daniel’s body.
It appeared to contain an uneaten meal, including fries and what investigators believed was a sandwich.
But the bag had something else on it.
A bloody handprint.
During testimony, a crime-scene investigator described seeing what appeared to be part of a bloody handprint on the bottom of the bag. He also recalled corresponding marks on the carpet nearby.
The observation immediately raised questions.
How had blood gotten onto the bag?
Had someone leaned against it while trying to stand?
Had someone touched it after coming into contact with Daniel?
Or had the bag been disturbed during the struggle described by Lacy?
The investigator explained that the marks indicated someone with blood on their person had come into contact with the bag.
But that observation alone did not establish who made the print or precisely when it happened.
The distinction mattered.
The prosecution could point to the handprint as evidence consistent with its reconstruction of the scene.
The defense could challenge whether the print actually established the sequence of events.
2. The Evidence That Was Photographed but Not Collected
A particularly important detail emerged during questioning.
The McDonald’s bag had been photographed, but the investigator said he did not collect it as evidence.
Why?
He explained that the bag appeared consistent with information he had received from the lead detective. That information suggested Boles had been over Daniel and had blood on her.
The investigator described the bag as consistent with someone pressing a hand down for support while getting up from the floor.
But there was a limitation.
He acknowledged that the information about Boles had come from the broader investigation. He was not independently establishing that she had made the handprint.
And because the bag had not been collected, the jury was left with photographs and the observations of investigators rather than a preserved bag available for additional examination.
That created an important question for the defense:
Could additional testing have identified whose blood or handprint was present?
And if so, why had the bag not been preserved?
The prosecution, meanwhile, could argue that the photographs documented an important part of the scene.
The bag became more than discarded fast food.
It became a disputed piece of evidence.
3. The Fallen McDonald’s Cup
The bag was not the only item that attracted attention.
Investigators also described a McDonald’s cup near Daniel’s body.
The cup appeared to have been knocked over. Its lid was separated, and liquid was visible around it.
One investigator testified that he did not see ice when he examined the area.
The cup's position raised another question.
Had Daniel dropped it when he was shot?
Had it been knocked over during a struggle?
Or had it been disturbed when someone moved around the body?
The available observations did not answer those questions conclusively.
But the cup mattered because Daniel had reportedly returned home with food shortly before his death.
The prosecution could use the condition of the meal and drink to help establish the circumstances surrounding his return.
The defense could point out that an overturned cup does not reveal who fired the gun.
4. The Blood Along the Stairs
Investigators also described blood in several locations.
There was blood near the basement area, along portions of the stairway, and on the front door and doorknob.
One responding officer recalled being careful around the front entrance because blood was present on the doorknob.
Another description of the scene included blood on the railing and areas along the route leading toward the basement.
These observations were important because the prosecution and defense had different explanations for how the blood came to be there.
The prosecution maintained that the physical evidence was consistent with its theory that Boles shot Daniel and then attempted to make the death appear self-inflicted.
The defense maintained that Boles had struggled with Daniel and tried to help him after the gun discharged.
If she had attempted CPR or fallen onto him, the defense could argue that blood transfer would not necessarily indicate that she had shot him.
The jury would have to consider the locations of the blood, the photographs, the testimony, and any scientific analysis presented during the trial.
Blood at a scene can tell investigators that contact occurred.
It does not automatically tell them who caused the fatal injury.
5. The Gun Near Daniel's Body
The firearm remained central to the investigation.
The prosecution had argued that the position of the weapon was inconsistent with Boles's account.
The defense disputed the prosecution's interpretation and maintained that Daniel had been holding the gun when Boles tried to intervene.
The scene photographs showed the weapon near Daniel.
But the question was not simply where the gun was found.
The question was how it got there.
Had Daniel been holding it when it discharged?
Had Boles been holding it?
Could a struggle have changed its position?
And what could the firearm examination establish about the shooting?
The photographs could document the scene.
They could not independently reconstruct every movement made in the basement.
That required the jury to consider the physical evidence alongside the testimony.
6. What the First Responders Remembered
The responding officers also provided important observations about the scene.
One officer described entering the home and seeing Daniel lying on his back with a gunshot wound to the head.
He recalled the McDonald's cup, the bag, blood in the basement, and blood on the firearm.
Another important detail was that some officers had limited involvement in the investigation.
They could describe what they personally observed.
They could not necessarily explain the forensic meaning of every stain or object.
That distinction became significant as the defense questioned what officers had actually seen, what they remembered, and what they had learned from other investigators.
A responding officer's observation was not the same thing as a laboratory conclusion.
And a photograph was not the same thing as a scientific reconstruction.
7. The Defense's Challenge
For the defense, the crime scene presented opportunities to question the investigation.
Why had the McDonald's bag not been collected?
Could the bloody handprint have been examined more thoroughly?
Were there additional tests that could have clarified the blood evidence?
Had investigators established whether Boles's account of falling onto Daniel was physically possible?
The defense wanted jurors to recognize that unanswered questions were not proof of guilt.
The prosecution had a different responsibility.
It had to demonstrate that the evidence supported the charges beyond a reasonable doubt.
A theory that sounded suspicious was not enough.
The state needed evidence that connected Boles to an intentional killing.
8. The Handprint That Remained a Mystery
By the end of the crime-scene testimony, the McDonald's bag had become one of the most intriguing objects in the case.
It had been photographed.
It had been described by investigators.
It had a bloody mark that appeared to resemble a handprint.
But the bag had not been collected for further examination.
And the testimony did not establish the identity of the person who left the mark.
For the prosecution, it was a detail that fit the theory of a bloody encounter in the basement.
For the defense, it was an example of evidence that had not been fully preserved or scientifically explained.
The jury would have to decide how much weight to give it.
And there was still another question waiting beneath all the others.
If Lacy Boles had been trying to save Daniel, did the blood evidence support her account?
Or did the overall scene suggest something much more deliberate?
The bag could not answer that question by itself.
Neither could the cup.
Neither could the photographs.
But together, the details formed a picture that both sides wanted the jury to see differently.
End of Chapter 24
Accuracy note: This chapter reflects reported crime-scene testimony from the first two trial days. The bloody handprint was observed and photographed, but the reporting does not establish that investigators identified who made it. The investigator's explanation about someone using the bag for support was an interpretation, not a confirmed forensic finding. ScribeHawk
Next chapter: Chapter 25 — The Police Interrogation: Lacy's Own Words and the Questions Investigators Wouldn't Let Go.
Sources & Notes
AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.