Chapter 28: Inside the Digital Evidence — The Phone Investigators Couldn't Unlock
For days, the jury had been hearing about the arguments between Lacy Jolee Boles and Daniel Akers.
They had seen the final text messages.
They had heard Lacy's explanation of the night Daniel died.
They had examined photographs of the basement and the objects surrounding his body.
But there was another potential source of information.
The phones.
Investigators had collected electronic devices connected to the case, hoping to retrieve information that might help reconstruct the events surrounding December 22, 2019.
Now the jury was learning what investigators had actually recovered.
And what they had failed to access.
1. Lieutenant Tyler Brown Takes the Stand
The prosecution called Tyler Brown, a lieutenant with the Paulding County Sheriff's Office.
At the time of the investigation, Brown had worked as a detective assigned to the Crimes Against Children Unit.
Part of his work involved technology-related investigations and extracting information from electronic devices.
He explained that investigators had asked him to help retrieve data from phones connected to the Boles investigation.
He attempted to extract information from two devices.
One extraction was successful.
The other was not.
The distinction would become important.
2. What Investigators Retrieved From Lacy's Phone
Brown testified that he successfully extracted a limited amount of data from a device identified as Lacy's personal phone.
He explained that the amount of information recoverable from a phone depends on the particular device and its condition.
Some phones allow investigators to retrieve only certain categories of information.
That might include text messages or call logs.
Other devices may allow access to a much larger portion of the phone's file system.
Brown testified that he turned the recovered data over to the detective handling the investigation.
But the testimony did not establish that every message, photograph, deleted conversation, or application record had been recovered.
The word limited mattered.
The jury needed to understand that investigators had not necessarily obtained a complete picture of everything stored on the device.
3. The iPhone That Wouldn't Open
The second device presented a much bigger challenge.
Brown identified it as an iPhone 6S.
It was locked, and investigators did not have a working passcode.
They attempted to use a forensic system called GrayKey.
The system repeatedly attempted to guess the passcode.
Brown explained that it could cycle through a large number of possibilities.
The effort continued for an extraordinary length of time.
According to his testimony, the device was subjected to the process for close to three years, although it had to be removed and restarted at various points.
Eventually, the phone stopped functioning.
Brown said he had no reasonable expectation that the system would successfully unlock it, so he returned it to the evidence vault.
Three years.
That was how long investigators had attempted to access information on the device during Brown's involvement.
And still, they had not succeeded.
4. Was the Information Ever Recovered?
During cross-examination, defense attorney Raymond Lale asked Brown whether the second phone had eventually yielded information.
Brown believed that it had.
But he made clear that he was not the person who later obtained the information.
He had left that unit and was no longer responsible for the device.
This created another important question for the jury:
If someone else eventually accessed the phone, what information was recovered?
Was it relevant to the shooting?
Did it contain communications between Daniel and Lacy?
Could it help establish the timeline?
The testimony from Brown alone did not answer those questions.
It established that one phone had yielded limited data and that another had resisted the initial extraction effort.
The jury would need additional evidence before deciding what significance the second device held.
5. The Defense Examines the Extraction
The defense did not simply accept the description of the extraction process.
Lale questioned Brown about the limits of his involvement.
Brown confirmed that his primary role was attempting to extract information from the devices.
He also acknowledged preparing reports and producing data sets.
The defense explored whether another investigator later performed additional work on the iPhone 6S.
Brown believed someone had eventually succeeded, but he could not identify the details from his own personal involvement.
That distinction was important.
A witness can testify about what he personally did.
He cannot automatically establish what another investigator later discovered.
The jury would have to hear from the person who performed any later extraction if the prosecution intended to rely on that work.
6. A New Detective Takes Over
After Brown's testimony, the prosecution called Detective Nicholas Hardy.
Hardy had worked in criminal investigations for the Paulding County Sheriff's Office.
He explained that he became involved in the Boles investigation in February 2020, after Detective Thomas Ogden was transferred out of the criminal investigations division.
Hardy was assigned as the lead detective.
But he had not been present when Daniel died.
He had not conducted the earliest stages of the investigation.
He inherited a case that another investigator had already begun.
That meant he needed to understand what had happened before he could decide what investigative steps remained necessary.
7. Starting From the Beginning
Hardy explained that he began by reviewing the original incident report.
He then examined the investigative materials already collected.
These included:
The original police report.
Interviews and witness statements.
Crime-scene photographs.
The 911 call.
Recorded interviews with Lacy.
Her written statement.
Available evidence inventories and records.
He described reviewing the material from the beginning rather than simply accepting another investigator's conclusions.
The process took time.
He testified that reviewing the material took days and extended over a period of weeks.
For the prosecution, this helped explain how Hardy became familiar with the case and why he was assigned responsibility for directing the investigation.
For the defense, the change in investigators created opportunities to examine how information had been transferred, interpreted, and pursued.
A detective who inherits a case must rely on records and evidence created by others.
That does not automatically make the investigation unreliable.
But it makes documentation especially important.
8. The Questions About the Original Investigation
Hardy acknowledged that he had reviewed the recorded interview conducted by Ogden several times.
He had also read Lacy's written statement.
He had examined the crime-scene photographs.
The defense could question whether the original investigation had preserved every possible piece of evidence.
The prosecution could argue that Hardy's review helped identify inconsistencies and additional investigative avenues.
But there was an important distinction between reviewing evidence and personally witnessing the events.
Hardy could explain what he did during the investigation.
He could describe the reports and photographs he reviewed.
He could not personally testify to what happened inside the basement before police arrived.
That remained the central issue for the jury.
9. The Digital Trail Is Not Complete
The phone testimony changed the picture.
In the previous chapter, the question was whether investigators had examined the phones and whether deleted messages might have been recovered.
Now the jury had more concrete information.
One device yielded a limited data extraction.
Another iPhone 6S could not initially be unlocked despite an extended effort using GrayKey.
Brown believed another investigator eventually extracted information from that second device.
But the testimony did not yet explain what that later extraction contained.
The phones had not produced a simple answer.
They had produced another series of questions.
10. What Did the Phones Know?
For the prosecution, the digital evidence could potentially help establish communications, timing, and the relationship between Lacy and Daniel.
For the defense, the limits of the extraction raised questions about completeness and whether investigators had obtained all available information.
Neither side could simply assume what the phones contained.
The jury would need to hear the actual records and the testimony of the people who recovered and interpreted them.
And Detective Hardy's testimony introduced another important subject:
How did the investigation change when he took over?
What did he discover that earlier investigators had not?
And what evidence ultimately persuaded authorities that Daniel's death was a homicide rather than a suicide?
Those questions would lead the jury deeper into the investigation.
Because the case was no longer just about the final argument between a husband and wife.
It was about every decision made afterward.
Every interview.
Every photograph.
Every recovered message.
And every piece of evidence that might explain what happened in that basement.
End of Chapter 28
Accuracy note: This chapter follows the November 13 testimony of Lieutenant Tyler Brown and Detective Nicholas Hardy. Brown testified that he recovered limited data from Boles's phone and could not initially unlock the iPhone 6S. He believed another investigator later succeeded. The exact contents of that later extraction should not be assumed without further testimony. Rev
Next chapter: Chapter 29 — Detective Hardy's Investigation: What Changed When He Took Over the Case?
Sources & Notes
AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.