Chapter 25: The Police Interrogation — Lacy's Story Under Pressure
The courtroom had heard the arguments.
It had seen photographs of the basement.
It had examined the McDonald's bag and the bloody handprint.
But now the jury was being given something more personal: Lacy Jolee Boles's own account of the night her husband died.
Investigators had interviewed her multiple times.
They had listened to her descriptions of Daniel's behavior, the arguments, the gun, and the moments after the shooting.
But during the third recorded interview, the questions became more direct.
Investigators were no longer simply asking what happened.
They were challenging whether her version could be true.
1. A Husband Acting Differently
In the interview, Lacy described Daniel as behaving unusually in the days before his death.
She suggested that he might have been using drugs and experiencing paranoia.
She described him as distant and suspicious, particularly on December 21, 2019.
One incident involved Daniel's reaction when her father arrived with food for the children.
According to Lacy, Daniel questioned why her father had brought food when there was already food in the house.
She considered the reaction unusual.
She also described Daniel as becoming suspicious that she was recording him.
These were Lacy's descriptions of his behavior. They were not, by themselves, proof that Daniel had been using drugs that day.
But they were important to the defense theory.
If Daniel had been behaving irrationally, the defense could argue that his actions inside the basement were consistent with a suicide attempt.
The prosecution, however, had a different interpretation.
It wanted jurors to focus on the arguments between the couple and the possibility that Lacy had confronted Daniel with a weapon.
2. The Alleged Assault
Lacy again described an earlier confrontation in the kitchen.
She said Daniel had grabbed her, choked her, and taken her cell phone.
She claimed she left the home with the children and went to her father's car lot.
She also described being upset and frightened by Daniel's behavior.
The defense could use this account to explain why Lacy wanted to leave the marriage and why she might have been concerned about Daniel returning home.
But there was another issue.
Investigators had to determine whether the alleged assault could be independently supported.
Were there injuries?
Had anyone seen her immediately afterward?
Had she told someone what happened?
And did the available evidence support her account?
The existence of an accusation did not automatically establish that the assault happened exactly as she described.
Likewise, the absence of a recorded statement at the time did not automatically establish that it was false.
The jury would have to evaluate the evidence.
3. The Swiffer Warning
One of the most unusual details in the case was the Swiffer mop and dustpan.
Lacy said she placed the items in a position where she would hear them fall if Daniel came home.
She explained that Daniel had a key and that she wanted to know if he returned.
The prosecution had described this arrangement as a possible warning system connected to a planned shooting.
The defense offered a different explanation.
Lacy had told Daniel not to come home. She wanted to know if he returned so she would not be surprised.
The same object could therefore support two competing interpretations.
Was it part of a plan?
Or was it simply a way to hear someone entering the house?
The answer depended on what the jury believed about the events that followed.
4. The Gun in Daniel's Hand
Lacy's account was that she heard the Swiffer items fall, got up, and followed Daniel downstairs.
She said she found him holding a gun near his mouth.
She recalled him saying words to the effect of:
"You can't save me. You can't help me."
She said she grabbed his forearm and screamed for him to stop.
Then the gun discharged.
This was the central part of her defense.
If the jury believed her account, the shooting could have been an accident during an attempt to prevent a suicide.
But investigators questioned the mechanics of that explanation.
They focused on what Lacy said she did with the gun and its holster after the shooting.
And that led to one of the most important confrontations in the interview.
5. The Safe and the Holster
Lacy described handling the gun and later placing a camouflage gun case back in the safe in the bedroom closet.
Investigators challenged that part of her account.
Their question was straightforward:
If she had handled the gun and holster in the way she described, why was there no corresponding blood evidence on those items?
The investigator suggested that the physical evidence did not support her explanation.
The prosecution could use this inconsistency to argue that Lacy's account was unreliable.
But the defense could question whether the absence of visible blood necessarily proved that she had not handled the items.
The jury would need to hear the relevant forensic evidence before deciding what that absence meant.
An interviewer's accusation is not a scientific finding.
And a defendant's explanation is not automatically proof.
The question was whether the evidence supported one account more strongly than the other.
6. The January 2022 Written Statement
The third interview was not the only account presented to jurors.
A sheriff's office investigator, Thomas Ogden, also read from an eight-page statement Lacy had written in January 2022.
She had been asked to describe what she remembered about December 21 and 22, 2019.
The statement included her account of Daniel's behavior, the alleged kitchen confrontation, the visit to her father's car lot, the argument, and the events after Daniel returned home.
She described hearing the Swiffer items fall.
She described following Daniel downstairs.
She described grabbing his arm and attempting CPR after the gun discharged.
The defense highlighted that the statement had been written continuously while she was being recorded.
That detail mattered because the defense wanted jurors to understand how the statement was prepared and to challenge any suggestion that it had been carefully rehearsed.
But the prosecution could still compare the written account with the recorded interviews and the physical evidence.
The jury now had several versions of Lacy's recollection to consider.
7. The Evidence the Police Did Not Preserve
During cross-examination, the defense turned its attention toward the investigation itself.
Brian Steel questioned Ogden about evidence that had not been collected or documented.
One particularly important issue was the lack of a recording of Lacy's initial explanation at the hospital.
The investigator acknowledged that he had not recorded that conversation, even though his phone had recording capabilities.
The defense argued that an important account had been lost.
Steel also questioned why investigators had not photographed Lacy's appearance and clothing when she was leaving the house or collected the clothing she had worn.
That omission became significant because the defense maintained that Lacy had fallen onto Daniel during the struggle and had blood on her from attempting CPR.
If her clothing had been preserved, the defense argued, it might have provided useful evidence.
The investigator acknowledged that the clothing had not been collected.
This allowed the defense to argue that investigators had failed to preserve evidence that could have supported Lacy's account.
The prosecution could respond that the missing evidence did not establish that the shooting was accidental.
But the defense had raised a legitimate question about the completeness of the investigation.
8. Gunshot Residue: A Test That Wasn't Done
Another issue involved gunshot residue.
Investigators preserved Daniel's hands for testing.
But Lacy was not tested for gunshot residue.
The defense explored why.
If Lacy had fired the weapon, gunshot residue might have been present on her hands or clothing.
However, the defense also acknowledged an important limitation: Lacy had washed her hands, and washing can remove or reduce residue.
That meant testing her later might not have provided a reliable answer.
Daniel's hands were tested, but the jury had not yet heard the scientific result during the testimony described in the November 13 coverage.
And even if residue were found on Daniel, it would not automatically prove he fired the gun.
A person can acquire gunshot residue through proximity to a discharged firearm.
The test could provide another piece of evidence.
It could not independently settle the entire case.
9. The Investigator's Body-Language Testimony
The defense also objected when the lead investigator discussed looking at suspects' body language during interviews.
Brian Steel argued that the investigator was moving into territory that belonged to the jury: deciding whether Lacy was telling the truth.
The defense requested a mistrial.
The prosecution disputed the characterization, maintaining that the questions concerned general investigative practices rather than an expert opinion about Lacy's credibility.
The judge denied the mistrial request.
The testimony was not struck.
The distinction was important.
The investigator could describe his general approach to interviewing suspects.
But the jury—not the investigator—was responsible for deciding whether Lacy's statements were truthful.
The defense had lost that particular motion, but it had made its objection clear.
10. Two Accounts, One Fatal Night
By the end of the third day, the jury had heard a substantial portion of Lacy's recorded account and her written statement.
The prosecution had highlighted details it believed contradicted suicide:
The couple's hostile messages.
The alleged argument before Daniel left.
The Swiffer arrangement.
The gun and holster.
The questions about blood evidence.
The absence of certain blood traces on items Lacy said she handled.
The defense had highlighted weaknesses in the investigation:
No recording of Lacy's initial hospital explanation.
No photographs documenting her appearance at the relevant time.
No preserved clothing.
No gunshot-residue testing of Lacy.
Questions about the handling and interpretation of the physical evidence.
Neither side had answered every question.
But the jury was beginning to see that this case would not be decided by one statement or one photograph.
It would be decided by whether the totality of the evidence supported the prosecution's claim of murder—or left reasonable doubt about the defense's explanation of an accidental shooting.
And one question remained especially important:
If Lacy was telling the truth about trying to stop Daniel, why did investigators believe the physical evidence contradicted her?
The next witnesses would help determine whether that challenge could be supported scientifically.
End of Chapter 25
This chapter is based on the reported November 13 proceedings, including testimony about Lacy's third interview, her January 2022 written statement, the investigator's cross-examination, and the defense's unsuccessful mistrial request. The scientific results of Daniel's gunshot-residue testing were not established in the coverage used here. scribehawk.com
Next chapter: Chapter 26 — The Gunshot Residue Test: What Did the Laboratory Find on Daniel's Hands?
Sources & Notes
AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.