True Crime Today

Chapter 13: The Investigators Take the Stand

True Crime TodayByValerie Harvey@investigativejournalist

Chapter 13 brings the investigators into the spotlight. The central question becomes whether the police followed the evidence wherever it led—or whether the investigation became focused too early on one suspect.

Chapter 13: The Investigators Take the Stand

A murder investigation is supposed to begin with questions.

Who died?

How did it happen?

Who was present?

What evidence remains?

And perhaps most importantly: What actually happened?

But when a case reaches trial, those questions become more complicated. Every decision made by investigators can be examined, challenged, and questioned.

In the trial of Lacy Jolee Boles, the prosecution had presented a theory of a planned killing. The defense had offered an entirely different explanation involving a struggle over a firearm.

Now the investigation itself became an important part of the story.

THE FIRST INVESTIGATIVE QUESTIONS

Daniel Akers was dead.

His death had been classified as a homicide by the medical examiner, and Boles had eventually been arrested and charged.

But a homicide classification did not answer the central question facing the jury.

Who was responsible?

Investigators had to consider the physical evidence, the circumstances surrounding the shooting, and the statements attributed to Boles.

They also had to reconstruct the events leading up to Daniel's death.

The prosecution's opening statement suggested that the couple's relationship had deteriorated amid arguments over money and other problems.

The defense, however, described a relationship in which Boles had allegedly experienced physical aggression and had told Daniel she wanted a divorce.

Those competing accounts made the couple's history relevant.

But relationship problems alone could not establish murder.

The jury would have to determine whether the investigation connected the circumstances to the actual shooting.

THE STATEMENTS

One of the most important categories of evidence in a criminal investigation is what the people involved said afterward.

According to the case account presented during opening statements, Boles told police that an argument had become physical on December 21, 2019.

She reportedly described Daniel pushing her against a wall, choking her, and taking her phone.

That account could become important to both sides.

The prosecution's perspective:

Prosecutors could argue that Boles's statements should be considered alongside the physical evidence and the alleged preparations involving the mop.

The defense's perspective:

The defense could argue that her description of the argument helped explain why she feared Daniel's return and why the subsequent encounter could have ended in an accidental shooting.

The investigators' handling of those statements would matter.

Were the statements documented accurately?

Were they consistent?

Were important details clarified?

Were investigators able to corroborate or contradict any part of the account?

These are legitimate questions for examination, but the answers must come from the actual testimony and evidence presented in court.

THE TIMELINE

A criminal case often depends on establishing a reliable timeline.

In this case, the prosecution described Daniel leaving the home, going to a bar, stopping at McDonald's, and returning shortly after midnight.

The state alleged that Boles had placed the mop against the door before his return.

The defense disputed the meaning of that action and maintained that the fatal encounter occurred when Boles attempted to stop Daniel from shooting himself.

The timeline could help the jury evaluate both versions.

Investigators might be asked to explain what information they used to establish Daniel's movements, when particular statements were obtained, and how they reconstructed the events inside the home.

But a timeline is only as reliable as its supporting evidence.

A statement, a photograph, a forensic finding, and a witness observation do not all carry the same evidentiary weight.

The jury would have to consider where the information came from and whether it could be independently verified.

DID INVESTIGATORS CONSIDER THE DEFENSE THEORY?

This was potentially one of the most important areas of dispute.

The defense described a struggle over a gun.

If that was what happened, the physical evidence might be interpreted differently than if the shooting had been deliberate.

A careful investigation would need to consider whether the available evidence supported or contradicted the possibility of a struggle.

Questions could include:

Was the firearm examined for fingerprints or other trace evidence?

Were the hands of the people involved examined for relevant forensic evidence?

Were photographs taken of the scene before evidence was moved?

Did investigators document the position of the gun?

Were alternative explanations for the shooting considered?

Were any potentially inconsistent findings investigated?

These are questions the defense could explore during testimony. They should not be mistaken for findings that have already been established in the reported trial coverage.

The prosecution would have its own opportunity to explain why investigators believed the evidence supported its theory.

THE PROBLEM WITH ASSUMPTIONS

There is a danger in any homicide investigation: once investigators develop a theory, they may begin interpreting later information through that theory.

That does not mean investigators in this case necessarily made that mistake.

It does mean the defense has a legitimate opportunity to examine how the investigation developed.

Did investigators begin with an open mind?

Did they test the prosecution's theory against the available evidence?

Did they investigate the possibility of an accidental discharge?

Did they distinguish between facts they could prove and conclusions they believed were reasonable?

The prosecution would argue that the evidence supports its charges.

The defense would be entitled to challenge the strength of that evidence.

And the jury would ultimately decide whether the state's case met the required standard of proof.

THE BIGGER QUESTION

The investigators may have been able to establish that Daniel died from a gunshot wound.

They may have documented the scene, collected evidence, and obtained statements.

But the most difficult question remained unanswered:

What happened during the final moments between Daniel and Lacy?

Was the shooting the result of a calculated decision, as the prosecution alleged?

Or was it an accident during a struggle, as the defense claimed?

The physical evidence would matter.

The medical findings would matter.

The statements would matter.

And the credibility of the witnesses would matter.

But the jury could not simply choose the story that sounded more convincing.

It had to decide whether the evidence proved the charges beyond a reasonable doubt.

As the trial continued, one question would become increasingly important:

Would Lacy Boles eventually take the stand and tell the jury her version of what happened?

If she did, the prosecution would have an opportunity to challenge her account directly.

If she did not, the jury would have to evaluate the defense through the evidence and testimony presented without hearing her testify.

Either way, the most important confrontation in the courtroom might still be ahead.

END OF CHAPTER 13

Next: Chapter 14 — The Defense Builds Its Case: Accident, Self-Defense, or Something Else?

Note: This chapter distinguishes the reported opening-statement claims from questions that may arise during witness examination. It does not present hypothetical questions as actual courtroom testimony.

Sources & Notes

CourtTV Courtroom Trial Live Updates - Lacy J. Boles

AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.