Paterson Men's Shelter Wins Court Stay, But Faces Dec. 7 Deadline to Pay Back Rent
PATERSON — A 40-bed men's shelter in Paterson came within hours of closing this week, a week before Thanksgiving and with winter approaching.
On Wednesday morning, Nov. 18, about 30 men left the shelter at 8 a.m. as they normally do, expecting to return at 4 p.m. When they came back, the locks on the front door had been changed.
The shelter's operator, St. Paul's Community Development Corporation, went to court later that same day. A judge granted a stay that lets the shelter stay open until a hearing on Dec. 7.
By that hearing, both sides say, the operator must pay its back rent, present a plan to secure the debt, or leave the building.
The building is owned by St. Paul's Episcopal Church. The church started the shelter about 50 years ago and later turned over day-to-day operations to the community development group, which shares the church's name.
A court order issued on Nov. 2 said the operator owed the church $150,721. That order said a warrant for removal would allow the landlord to take possession of the property.
The Rev. Erik Soldwedel, St. Paul's pastor, said the church has not received any rent payment from the shelter operator since June 2025, including money for utilities and garbage disposal. He said the missed payments have left the church's own finances, in his words, "extremely precarious," and forced the congregation to use its cash reserves to pay its bills.
"It's not a church evicting a homeless shelter," Soldwedel said. "It's the church removing the community development corporation that runs a shelter in that space."
"This was not an easy decision," he said. "We don't want to say to these men that you don't have a place to stay. That's not something we take lightly. It's the kind of thing that keeps you up at night."
Richard Williams, executive director of the nonprofit that operates the shelter, said his group had been trying to negotiate an agreement to keep the shelter open through the winter. He called the lockout "self-defeating."
"They're putting these homeless guys out on the street a week before Thanksgiving," Williams said before the court intervened.
Williams said his organization has used a $50,000 grant from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, passed through city government, to pay rent. He said that until 2024 the city sent the money in four installments a year, but in the past couple of years it has come in one lump sum, well into the following year. He said his group waited until this past September to receive its funding for 2025, and that city officials have blamed the change on HUD's revised practices.
Soldwedel said the operator should have passed along the $50,000 it received to cover rent arrears. Williams said the church had already made clear it wanted the shelter out, so his group began looking for what he called "alternative accommodations."
The city gave a different account. Mayor Andre Sayegh did not respond to a request for comment. His public information officer, Diana Nunez, said the shelter operators never signed a grant agreement that would have continued the $50,000 in funding, so the city has not been able to process the payments.
"Additionally, the organization has not returned phone calls or responded to emails from its assigned program monitor and supervisor regarding this matter," Nunez said.
The stakes go beyond one building. A statewide count of unhoused residents in 2025 found 336 people in Paterson living in shelters or on the streets. Several months ago Mayor Sayegh hired what he called a "homeless czar" to address the problem.
Roberta Farber, a social worker at a family shelter run by the Paterson Alliance, reacted to news of the lock change by asking where the men would go. "This is going to have major impact," Farber said. "Where are they going to go? The problem is there's no other place for them to go."
Councilwoman Ruby Cotton called the eviction of the shelter "horrible" and said, "I hope they can work things out." Councilman Luis Velez said he wants everyone involved to address the matter immediately to prevent further delays in funding and services.
In the summer of 2025, Williams' organization also shut down a food pantry it had been operating out of the basement of the same building.
Soldwedel said no decision has been made on what to do with the shelter space if the operator leaves. "I don't see it ever being used as a shelter again," he said.
For now, the men have a place to return to each afternoon. What happens after Dec. 7 will depend on whether the rent is paid, a plan is accepted, or the court orders the shelter to vacate.
Sources & Notes: This story is based on reporting by NorthJersey.com / Paterson Press, "Paterson homeless shelter evades eviction with court help," published Nov. 19, 2026. All facts, names, figures and quotes were verified against that source on Nov. 19, 2026.
Sources & Notes
AI wrote a first draft from the writer's own reporting. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.