Late-Counted Ballots Flip Final Paterson School Board Race

PATERSON — The last seat on Paterson's Board of Education changed hands on Friday, Nov. 13, when late-counted ballots pushed incumbent school commissioner Mohammed Rashid past challenger Chris Small, according to results released by Passaic County election officials and reported by NorthJersey.com's Paterson Press.

Small had held a slim 63-vote lead while the count dragged on for days after Election Day. That lead disappeared when officials tallied a final surge of 444 mail-in and provisional votes on Friday. The final numbers put Rashid ahead, 7,869 to 7,728 — a margin of 141 votes, or less than a fraction of a percentage point.

https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/paterson-press/2026/11/14/mohammed-rashid-wins-final-seat-paterson-board-of-education-race/92779364007/ · northjersey.com

The other two seats were never in much doubt. Kenneth Simmons, Paterson's longest-serving school commissioner, finished as the top vote-getter with 9,011 votes. Board President Joel Ramirez took the second seat with 8,270 votes.

Behind the top four, Banita Herndon finished with 5,158 votes, followed by Madelen Lemoine with 4,316 and Sumaidah "Sam" Ramadan with 3,146.

The close finish closed out a hard year for the Paterson school district. According to the Paterson Press report, the community has protested the elimination of the city's school choice programs, along with changes in special education and the reduction of more than 300 jobs in budget cuts. District officials are also working on a plan that could split the city's gifted and talented academy, a school that has been named the top school in New Jersey four times in the past six years.

Those fights shaped the election. Simmons and Small opposed the changes, while Ramirez and Rashid, both loyal supporters of Superintendent Laurie Newell, backed most of them. Mayor Andre Sayegh, City Council President Lilisa Mimms, and Council Vice President Maritza Davila endorsed Ramirez and Rashid, as did three other council members and several school board colleagues.

Rashid works as an inspector for Paterson's municipal government, and Ramirez is the city's health and human services director. The Paterson Press noted that they are two of five city employees who also serve as unpaid school board members.

For ten days after the election, the outcome of the third seat stayed up in the air while the final ballots were counted. Paterson has seen this before — school elections here often come down to the last batches of mail-in votes, and this year was no exception.

With the results now final, the board keeps the team that has supported the superintendent's direction. The debates that drove the campaign — over choice schools, special education, jobs, and the gifted academy — will now move from the campaign trail back to the board table, where the winners will have to answer for them.

Sources & Notes

NorthJersey.com / Paterson Press, "Late-counted ballots flip final Paterson school board race," Nov. 14, 2026 — https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/paterson-press/2026/11/14/mohammed-rashid-wins-final-seat-paterson-board-of-education-race/92779364007/ . Vote totals and results as released by Passaic County election officials and reported by Paterson Press. Facts verified against the source before publishing.

AI wrote a first draft from the writer's own reporting. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.