True Crime Today

Chapter 18: Inside the Basement

True Crime TodayByValerie Harvey@investigativejournalist

Reconstructing the Final Moments

There was one place in the Akers home that mattered more than anywhere else.

The basement.

According to the prosecution, this was where Lacy Jolee Boles followed her husband and shot him in the face.

According to the defense, this was where Boles found Daniel holding a gun and desperately tried to stop him from taking his own life.

One location.

One fatal gunshot.

Two completely different explanations.

For the jury, understanding the basement could be essential to understanding what happened during the final moments of Daniel Akers's life.

THE SCENE

When investigators examine a suspected homicide, the crime scene becomes a collection of details.

The position of the victim.

The location of the firearm.

The surrounding objects.

The condition of the room.

Any physical evidence that might help establish what happened.

But a crime scene is not a recording.

It cannot show investigators every movement that occurred before the fatal injury.

Instead, investigators must document what they find and use the available evidence to reconstruct events.

In this case, the prosecution emphasized that Daniel was found with the firearm near his right hand.

The defense described him holding the weapon in his left hand before the shooting.

That discrepancy made the documentation of the scene particularly important.

What did investigators actually observe?

What did photographs preserve?

Were any objects moved before they were documented?

Those questions could become significant during testimony.

THE PROSECUTION'S RECONSTRUCTION

The state offered a sequence of events during opening statements.

According to prosecutor Jason Treadaway, Boles allegedly anticipated Daniel's return and placed a Swiffer mop against a door to alert her when he came inside.

Daniel reportedly left the home, visited a bar, stopped at McDonald's, and returned shortly after midnight.

The prosecution alleged that Boles followed him into the basement and shot him once in the face.

The state wanted jurors to view the mop and the circumstances of Daniel's return as evidence of preparation.

Its theory suggested that the basement encounter was not an unexpected accident.

It was the conclusion of a deliberate sequence.

But the prosecution would need to support that reconstruction with evidence.

The location of the objects, the physical findings, the timeline, and the testimony of investigators could all matter.

THE DEFENSE'S RECONSTRUCTION

The defense described a very different scene.

According to Brian Steel, Boles had told Daniel not to return because she intended to pursue a divorce.

When she encountered him in the basement, he allegedly had a gun in his left hand, pointed toward his mouth.

The defense said Daniel made a statement suggesting that nobody could help him.

Boles allegedly lunged toward him.

The firearm discharged.

Daniel died.

Under this explanation, the basement was not the scene of a planned execution.

It was the location of a sudden struggle.

The defense would need to challenge the prosecution's reconstruction and show why the available evidence did not establish an intentional shooting beyond a reasonable doubt.

THE IMPORTANCE OF PHOTOGRAPHS

Crime-scene photographs can become powerful courtroom exhibits.

They allow jurors to see what investigators documented rather than relying entirely on verbal descriptions.

Photographs may show:

The layout of the room.

The location of visible objects.

The position in which evidence was documented.

The relationship between different areas of the scene.

Physical details that may be difficult to describe accurately in testimony.

But photographs have limitations.

They capture a particular moment.

They do not necessarily explain how objects arrived in their final positions.

They cannot independently establish who moved an object or why it was placed somewhere.

A photograph of the gun near Daniel's right hand, for example, would document its location when photographed.

It would not automatically establish which hand held it when the gun discharged.

That distinction could become important.

THE SWIFFER MOP RETURNS

The mop remained an unusual but potentially significant part of the prosecution's theory.

Why was it placed against the door?

Was it positioned in a way that would alert someone when the door opened?

Was it intended to make noise or obstruct movement?

Could investigators establish exactly how it had been arranged?

The prosecution wanted jurors to interpret the mop as evidence that Boles anticipated Daniel's return.

The defense wanted jurors to understand it as a warning system used by someone who did not want an unwanted confrontation.

The physical object could be documented.

Its purpose would have to be evaluated through the surrounding circumstances and the evidence.

WHAT A RECONSTRUCTION CAN AND CANNOT PROVE

Crime-scene reconstruction can help investigators evaluate competing explanations.

But it is important not to confuse a reconstruction with a direct observation of the event.

A reconstruction depends on assumptions and available information.

If an important detail is wrong, the resulting explanation may also be wrong.

For example:

If investigators assume that the gun remained where it was found throughout the incident, they may interpret the scene differently than if the weapon was moved.

If they assume that a person approached from one direction, the interpretation of other evidence may change.

That is why defense attorneys often examine the assumptions behind an investigative reconstruction.

The prosecution, in turn, may present experts or investigators who explain why their interpretation is supported.

The jury must evaluate the reliability of the conclusions.

THE ABSENCE OF A WITNESS

The fatal encounter took place inside the home.

The competing accounts presented during opening statements came from the prosecution and defense—not from an independent eyewitness account of the shooting.

That made the physical evidence especially important.

Daniel could not testify.

Boles's version, as described by the defense, would need to be evaluated against the other evidence.

The prosecution's reconstruction would also need to withstand examination.

The jury would have to determine whether the state's evidence was strong enough to establish what happened beyond a reasonable doubt.

THE FINAL MOMENTS

Imagine the questions the jury would carry into deliberations:

Where was Daniel standing?

Where was Boles?

Who had the firearm?

What happened immediately before the shot?

Could a struggle have occurred?

Was the weapon's final position consistent with either account?

Did the physical evidence support the prosecution's allegation of preparation?

Or did it leave room for the defense's explanation of an accidental discharge?

These questions were not merely details.

They went directly to the heart of the case.

THE BASEMENT CANNOT SPEAK

The basement held the physical evidence of a terrible event.

But it could not explain the intentions of the people inside it.

The prosecution believed the evidence would reveal a planned killing.

The defense believed the evidence would expose weaknesses in that theory and support an accidental-shooting explanation.

For the jury, the challenge was to separate what could be established from what could only be inferred.

The gun was there.

Daniel was dead.

And Boles stood accused of causing his death.

But the most important question remained unresolved:

Could the state prove that the shooting was intentional, or would the evidence leave the jury with reasonable doubt?

The next stage of the case would turn toward the people who knew the couple.

Their testimony could help explain the marriage, the arguments, and the circumstances leading up to December 21, 2019.

But personal relationships can complicate a murder trial.

Some witnesses may remember events differently.

Some may have loyalties.

And some may know things that neither side wants the jury to overlook.

END OF CHAPTER 18

Next: Chapter 19 — Friends, Family, and Witnesses: What Did They Know About the Marriage?

Accuracy note: This chapter reconstructs the competing theories introduced in opening statements. It does not claim that particular crime-scene photographs, measurements, or reconstruction testimony have been presented unless confirmed by trial reporting.

Sources & Notes

Court TV Courtroom Live Updates--Lacy J. Boles

AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.