Chapter 31: The First Responders — What Did Police See in the Basement?
The first officers to arrive at the Akers home on December 22, 2019, were not walking into an ordinary emergency.
They were responding to a report of a man who had suffered a gunshot wound.
Inside the house, Lacy Boles was waiting for help. Her husband, Daniel Akers, lay in the basement. Their children were also inside the home.
By the time the case reached trial, the first responders' memories had become an important part of the prosecution's effort to reconstruct what happened.
But there was another question the defense wanted the jury to consider:
Had the scene remained exactly as it was when the gun was fired?
The First Deputy Arrives
Captain Brent Miller, who was a sergeant at the time, testified that he was the first law-enforcement officer to arrive.
He described finding Boles crying and screaming for help. She directed him toward the basement, where he found Akers.
Miller testified that the scene looked very bad. He observed the gunshot wound and items around the body, including a McDonald's bag and cup.
He also remembered the smell of McDonald's food in the room.
His immediate responsibilities were not to solve a murder. They were to make sure the scene was safe and determine whether anyone needed assistance.
During questioning, Miller acknowledged that he could not remember every detail from that night. He did not recall whether he had checked Akers for vital signs himself or whether he had touched the body.
Seven years had passed.
That gap in memory became significant when the defense began examining exactly what the first responders had done.
What Did the Officers Touch?
The prosecution needed the jury to understand that the crime scene had not been casually disturbed.
The defense, however, explored the possibility that emergency personnel could have affected the position of objects or the body before investigators arrived.
Miller testified that he could not remember every movement made during those first minutes.
Captain David Pace also testified about his arrival and the steps taken after he entered the home.
Pace said he and Miller were inside before the emergency medical personnel arrived. He described going downstairs briefly and later returning with the EMTs.
He did not remember seeing the pistol during his brief initial visit.
That answer did not establish that the gun had been moved. It established that Pace could not independently recall seeing it at that particular moment.
The distinction mattered.
A witness who remembers seeing an object is different from a witness who cannot remember whether it was there.
The McDonald's Bag and the Blood
The basement contained several details that would become important as the trial continued.
Witnesses described blood near the body, blood on the firearm, and blood on the McDonald's bag.
Deputy John Beall, who was training under another deputy when he responded, described seeing blood on the front door area and along the stairway.
Downstairs, he observed Akers lying on his back, a gun near his hand, and the McDonald's items.
The bag would later become the subject of particular attention because investigators reported seeing a bloody handprint on it.
But what did that handprint establish?
The presence of blood on the bag was one fact. Determining who left the print, when it was deposited, and what it meant about the sequence of events required additional evidence.
The bag had been photographed, but testimony later established that it had not been collected.
That omission gave the defense another issue to explore: whether an item that might have helped investigators answer questions about the scene had been preserved.
The EMTs Enter
Emergency medical personnel arrived after the deputies.
Pace testified that he accompanied them downstairs when they first entered. He remembered seeing them bend over Akers and check for signs of life.
He could not recall every specific action they performed.
The defense questioned whether the EMTs might have moved anything while assessing Akers.
Pace testified that, in his experience, emergency personnel generally came to check vital signs and signs of life—not to move evidence such as a firearm.
The prosecution also questioned whether it would be normal for an EMT to move a weapon in a scene where the person was already believed to be deceased.
The testimony did not establish that the EMTs had repositioned the gun.
Nor did it provide a perfect minute-by-minute record of every movement in the basement.
It left the jury with a narrower question: how much could the officers actually remember about the scene before it was secured?
The Missing Body-Camera Footage
Another issue surfaced during testimony.
The responding officers were not equipped with body-worn cameras in 2019.
That meant there was no body-camera recording showing precisely what the first officer saw when he entered the house, where each object was located, or how the first minutes unfolded.
The defense could question the witnesses about their memories, but it could not compare those memories against a continuous recording.
The prosecution, meanwhile, could point to the officers' testimony and the photographs taken during the investigation.
Neither side could produce footage that did not exist.
The absence of a recording did not prove that evidence had been disturbed. But it did make the witnesses' recollections especially important.
What Did the First Responders See Lacy Doing?
The officers also described Boles's condition when they arrived.
Miller testified that she was crying and screaming for help. He said his priority was to make sure the scene was safe and to determine whether anyone needed assistance.
He did not recall anything particularly unusual about her clothing.
He also acknowledged that he could not remember whether she had blood on her clothing.
That uncertainty was important because the prosecution and defense had very different interpretations of Boles's actions after the shooting.
The defense described a woman who had discovered her husband after an accidental discharge and desperately tried to save him.
The prosecution argued that her account did not fit the physical evidence and that the scene had been staged.
The first responders could describe what they saw.
They could not, simply from observing a distressed woman, establish what had happened before they arrived.
The Questions That Remained
By the end of the testimony, the jury had heard several details about the first minutes inside the home:
Miller was the first law-enforcement officer to arrive.
Boles was crying and asking for help.
Akers was found in the basement with a fatal gunshot wound.
A firearm and McDonald's items were observed near the body.
Blood was visible in several areas.
EMTs entered and assessed Akers.
The responding officers did not have body-camera footage from that night.
Some witnesses could not remember every movement or detail from the scene.
These facts were important, but they did not answer the central question.
Who fired the gun?
The prosecution would ask the jury to consider the physical evidence, the position of the firearm, the blood evidence, and Boles's changing explanations.
The defense would ask the jury to consider the possibility of an accidental discharge during a struggle—and whether investigators could rule that out beyond a reasonable doubt.
The first responders had arrived after the fatal moment.
They could tell the jury what they encountered.
They could not take the jury back in time.
And somewhere between the moment the gun fired and the moment the first deputy entered the basement lay the answer everyone in that courtroom was trying to find.
The first-responder testimony described above was reported from the trial's opening day; it is not presented as new testimony from Day 4. The case remains ongoing, and the competing accounts are allegations and defense arguments—not findings of guilt. courtroominsider.com
I will continue with Chapter 32, focusing on the forensic questions surrounding the gun and the position of Daniel's hand.
Sources & Notes
AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.