True Crime Today

Chapter 34: Two Versions of the Same Night — What Did Lacy Tell Investigators?

True Crime TodayByValerie Harvey@investigativejournalist

In a murder investigation, the first account can become one of the most important pieces of evidence.

It is given before days of questioning, before investigators have explained their theories, and before a suspect has had time to review every detail of the crime scene.

But an emergency call is not a complete account of everything that happened.

A person may be frightened, confused, injured, or struggling to process a traumatic event.

That is why investigators compare the first statements with later interviews.

In the case of Lacy Boles, one particular detail stands out:

What happened to the gun after Daniel Akers was shot?

The First Account: The 911 Call

The emergency call began shortly after midnight on December 22, 2019.

Lacy was asking for help. Daniel was downstairs, suffering from a catastrophic gunshot wound.

The dispatcher needed to know where the weapon was.

During the exchange, Lacy said the gun was still in Daniel's hand. She also told the dispatcher:

"I haven't touched it."

Those words would become important when investigators later questioned her about the firearm.

At that moment, the dispatcher was trying to establish the immediate circumstances and protect everyone in the home.

Lacy was emotional, and the conversation was not a formal police interrogation.

Nevertheless, the recording preserved what she said.

The Later Interview: A Different Detail Emerges

During a later recorded police interview, investigators asked Lacy to explain what happened after she encountered Daniel in the basement.

Her account was that Daniel had been holding the gun near his mouth.

She said she grabbed him in an attempt to stop him. According to her explanation, the gun discharged during the struggle.

But the questioning also addressed what happened to the weapon afterward.

Lacy told investigators that she picked it up because she wanted to make sure she was safe. She said she could not remember exactly where she put it and had previously described throwing it.

That raised an obvious question:

If the gun was still in Daniel's hand when she called 911, when did she pick it up?

The timing matters.

The defense maintains that Lacy was responding to an accidental shooting and trying to protect herself after the weapon discharged.

The prosecution argues that the circumstances surrounding the gun are inconsistent with her explanation.

The Question of Timing

There are several moments investigators and jurors must keep separate:

1. The moment Daniel was shot.

2. The moments immediately afterward, when Lacy says she tried to help him.

3. The moment she called 911.

4. The time emergency personnel and deputies arrived.

5. The later handling and documentation of the firearm.

A statement made during one of those moments cannot automatically establish what happened during another.

For example, saying the gun was still in Daniel's hand during the emergency call does not, by itself, establish where it was when the first deputy entered the basement.

Likewise, saying she later picked up the weapon does not establish exactly when she did so.

Those details must be compared with the testimony of the responding officers, photographs, and other evidence.

The Left-Hand Question

Another important part of Lacy's account concerned which hand Daniel was using.

She told investigators that the gun was in his left hand.

The defense has argued that Daniel was holding the weapon when she tried to intervene.

The prosecution has questioned the physical circumstances surrounding the firearm and the way it was found.

Investigators also examined the position of the weapon and the details of the scene.

But there is a distinction between a reported hand position and a scientifically established conclusion.

The jury must decide how much weight to give Lacy's description and whether it is consistent with the other evidence.

Why the Defense Challenges the Investigation

Brian Steel has repeatedly challenged the investigation.

His questions have included whether important evidence was collected, whether investigators properly documented the scene, and whether the medical examiner received all relevant information.

The defense has also highlighted limitations in the investigation, including the absence of certain recordings and photographs.

These issues matter because the defense wants jurors to consider whether investigators reached conclusions without fully resolving alternative explanations.

The prosecution, meanwhile, maintains that the evidence supports its allegation that Daniel was murdered.

Neither side gets to decide the facts simply by questioning the other side's work.

The jury must evaluate the evidence and the credibility of the witnesses.

Why the Prosecution Focuses on Inconsistencies

For prosecutors, differences between a person's first account and later explanations can be significant.

They may argue that a changing story reflects an effort to explain away evidence.

But not every difference proves deception.

A person experiencing a traumatic event may initially provide incomplete information. Memory can also be affected by stress and confusion.

The important question is whether the differences are meaningful and whether they can be reconciled with the rest of the evidence.

In this case, the firearm's position and handling are particularly important because they relate directly to the competing explanations of Daniel's death.

What the Jury Must Decide

The jury is not being asked simply whether Lacy sounded frightened during the 911 call.

Nor is it being asked whether every detail in her later interview was perfectly remembered.

The central questions are much more serious:

Was Daniel holding the gun when the fatal shot was fired?

Did Lacy grab him during an attempt to stop a suicide?

When was the firearm moved?

Does the physical evidence support an accidental discharge?

Or does the evidence support the prosecution's allegation that the scene was staged?

The answers must come from the complete record, not one sentence taken out of context.

Two Accounts, One Tragic Ending

Daniel Akers cannot explain what happened in the basement.

His final moments are reconstructed through the statements, recordings, photographs, and forensic evidence presented in court.

Lacy's 911 call captures her immediate request for help.

Her later interviews provide a more detailed explanation of what she says happened.

The prosecution sees contradictions that it believes point toward murder.

The defense sees an account of a chaotic accident that investigators failed to properly rule out.

The difference between those interpretations may ultimately determine the outcome of the trial.

And the question that remains is painfully simple:

When Lacy said the gun was still in Daniel's hand, was she describing exactly what she had seen—or was there more to the story than she initially told the dispatcher?

Reporting note: The 911 wording and the later account about picking up the firearm are drawn from the available trial transcript and courtroom reporting. The apparent difference is presented as an issue for the jury, not proof that either account is false. Rev

The next chapter can examine the messages exchanged between Daniel and Lacy in the hours before his death, including what they reveal—and what they cannot prove—about the couple's final evening.

Sources & Notes

Court TV Live Updates - Lacy J. Boles

AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.