Chapter 12: The Evidence That Could Make or Break the Case
Chapter 12 turns to the physical evidence: the gun, the bullet, the position of Daniel’s body, and the Swiffer mop that prosecutors say was part of a deliberate trap.
Chapter 12: The Evidence That Could Make or Break the Case
The opening statements had given the jury two dramatically different versions of December 21, 2019.
According to the prosecution, Lacy Jolee Boles had prepared for her husband's return. The Swiffer mop placed against the door was not an innocent household object. It was allegedly an early-warning device—a way to know when Daniel Akers came back inside.
The defense offered a different explanation.
Boles had allegedly told Daniel not to return because she intended to pursue a divorce. The mop, according to the defense, was meant to alert her if he came back, not to help her carry out a murder.
Now the case would turn toward the evidence.
And physical evidence does not always tell a story as clearly as either side wants the jury to believe.
THE GUN
At the center of the prosecution's case was a .22-caliber pistol.
Prosecutors alleged that Daniel was shot once in the face while inside the couple's home. During opening statements, the jury heard the prosecutor describe the bullet's entry through Daniel's left nostril and its path into his brain.
The weapon's reported position near Daniel's right hand also became important.
Why?
Because the defense described a very different scene.
According to defense attorney Brian Steel, Boles found Daniel holding the gun in his left hand and pointing it toward his mouth. The defense claimed Daniel made a disturbing statement suggesting that nobody could help him.
Boles allegedly lunged to stop him.
During the struggle, the gun discharged.
That explanation raised several questions:
Was the gun's position consistent with the defense's account?
Could the physical evidence establish whether a struggle occurred?
Were there fingerprints or other forensic findings that could help determine who handled the weapon?
Could the gun's condition or examination establish anything about how it was fired?
The jury would need evidence—not assumptions—to answer those questions.
THE BULLET'S PATH
The prosecution emphasized the fatal wound's location and trajectory.
But a bullet's path is only one part of a forensic investigation.
Investigators and medical experts may consider the entrance wound, the internal damage, the direction of travel, and any other physical findings that can help reconstruct the shooting.
The prosecution's interpretation could support its theory of an intentional shooting.
The defense, however, would have an opportunity to challenge whether those findings actually ruled out an accidental discharge during a struggle.
One critical distinction mattered:
A medical examiner's conclusion about the manner of death is not automatically a conclusion about who fired the weapon.
The medical examiner reportedly classified Daniel's death as a homicide. That meant the death was determined not to be self-inflicted. It did not, by itself, establish Boles's guilt.
That question belonged to the jury.
THE SWIFFER MOP
Perhaps no ordinary household object carried more importance in the prosecution's opening statement than the Swiffer mop.
Prosecutors described it as a device placed against a door so that Boles would know when Daniel returned.
The defense disputed the meaning behind it.
The same object could become two very different pieces of evidence depending on how the jury interpreted the surrounding circumstances.
For the prosecution, it suggested preparation.
For the defense, it suggested fear and an attempt to protect herself from an unwanted return.
But several details would matter:
Where exactly was the mop positioned?
Was there evidence showing how it had been placed?
Could investigators determine whether it had been moved?
Did photographs or other documentation preserve its original position?
And perhaps most importantly, was there evidence that established Boles's reason for putting it there?
The mop could not explain its own purpose.
Only the surrounding evidence and testimony could help the jury decide.
THE AUTOPSY
The medical examiner's findings had already played an important role in bringing the case to trial.
According to the reported case history, the Paulding County Sheriff's Office received the autopsy findings in May 2020. The medical examiner concluded that Daniel's fatal injury was not self-inflicted and classified the death as a homicide.
Boles was arrested on May 29, 2020.
The defense would have the opportunity to examine the medical conclusions, question the methods used, and challenge any interpretation that went beyond what the findings could reliably establish.
The prosecution, meanwhile, would need to connect the medical evidence to its larger theory of an intentional killing.
The autopsy could help explain how Daniel died.
It could not independently explain everything that happened in the basement.
TWO STORIES, ONE CRIME SCENE
The prosecution's version depended on a sequence of deliberate actions:
Boles allegedly anticipated Daniel's return, positioned the mop, waited for him, and then followed him into the basement before shooting him.
The defense's version depended on a sudden confrontation:
Daniel allegedly returned despite being told not to, was holding a gun, and a struggle began when Boles tried to stop him.
Both accounts placed the same two people in the same home.
Both involved the same firearm.
But they described entirely different intentions.
That was the central challenge for the jury.
It was not enough to determine that Daniel had been shot. The jury had to decide whether the state could prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Boles committed the charged crimes.
WHAT HAD NOT YET BEEN ESTABLISHED
At this stage of the reported trial coverage, the opening statements had introduced the competing theories, but the detailed forensic testimony had not yet been established in the reporting available for this chapter.
That distinction matters.
The prosecution's descriptions were allegations and promises about what it expected the evidence to show. The defense's explanation was an alternative account that would also need to be evaluated against the evidence.
Neither opening statement was proof.
The coming testimony would determine how much of either story survived examination.
And there was another question waiting beneath the surface:
If the physical evidence could not conclusively establish what happened during the final moments of Daniel's life, would the jury rely more heavily on the testimony of the people who investigated the case?
Or would the investigators themselves become the next focus of the courtroom battle?
The gun had a story.
The wound had a story.
The mop had a story.
But they did not necessarily tell the same one.
End of Chapter 12
Next: Chapter 13 — The Investigators Take the Stand. The focus shifts to the police investigation, the decisions investigators made, and whether the evidence was examined from every possible angle.
Sources & Notes
AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.