Essay

Sinners And The Plague Of Whiteness

Introduction

Rylan Coogler’s Sinners is an American horror film about twin brothers, Stack and Smoke, returning to their hometown in Mississippi to create a juke joint and have a fresh start in life. However, trouble awaits them from the supernatural world as a vampire named Remmick seeks to use their cousin named Sammie for his own gain and force everyone in the joint to assimilate to the vampire lifestyle. Many themes are present throughout this film, however, I will be discussing the film’s theme on whiteness. Specifically, I will be discussing how Sinners illustrates the way whiteness influences communities as well as the system of capitalism.

Section #1: Remmick’s Whiteness

Remmick, the main antagonist of Sinners, exhibits the plague of whiteness in a number of ways. His colorblind racism influences both his actions and motives throughout the film, illustrating the performative nature of his inclusivity. From the start, we see Remmick demonizing the Choctaw vampire hunters by painting himself as the victim to the film’s secondary antagonists, Bert and Joan. Here we can see Remmick utilizing his whiteness to paint the Choctaw as savages like settler colonists have historically done to the Native Americans. Bert and Joan give into his act because of their own racial biases towards the vampire hunters, even after they warn them of Remmick's presence. In a sense, they see Remmick as one of their own and they must protect him from anyone who threatens their whiteness.

https://screenrant.com/sinners-best-movie-2025-so-far-reasons/

From there on, Remmick’s motivations come into fruition when he shows up to the juke joint. When he meets the cast, he specifically targets Sammie for his Blues music along with his ability to conjure up the spirits and ancestors. Through Sammie’s music, Remmick seeks to bring back his ancestors from his Irish ancestry. Remmick’s Irish ancestry is an important part of his character because he uses this in attempts to lure Sammie into the vampire lifestyle. For context, Irish people suffered through British colonialism throughout the late 1800s to early 1900s and at the time they weren’t considered white enough to fit into the system of whiteness. This would change once Irish people settled in America, especially during Jim Crow with the way Black and white people were separated. Now what does this have to do with Remmick and Sammie?

Remmick uses this history in attempts to connect with Sammie on British colonialism while failing to realize that he is repeating the same actions of his oppressors. Similar to England’s contribution to the Transatlantic Slave Trade, Remmick uses a Black body—more specifically an enslaved Black man from a plantation—for his personal gain, hence continuing the cycle of oppression. Additionally, he engages in cultural appropriation as he flat out tells Sammie during the climax of the film, “I want your stories and I want your songs and you gonna have mine” ( Sinners, 2025 ). Through these lines, Remmick’s true colors show by illustrating how he isn’t actually looking for community, he just wants to steal from Black culture. His view of community is twisted by whiteness, forced integration, and cultural appropriation of Black creativity. But in Remmick’s eyes, he’s their savior! Through Remmick’s eyes, being a vampire is freedom—even if it requires death and never feeling the warmth of the sun. With that in mind, we must talk about the significance of the vampires in Sinners.

Section #2: Symbolism of Vampires

The vampires are a key part of the film, not just for the horror aspect but also their symbolism. Before discussing the symbolism, we need to discuss how the vampires work in Sinners. When a character gets turned, they pass away for a short time before getting resurrected due to getting bitten by a vampire. While the vampires are immortal, there are downsides such as not feeling the warmth of the sun or not having the ability to conjure spirits and ancestors. In other words, turning into a vampire comes at a cost.

With that said, the vampires symbolize assimilation, more specifically assimilation to whiteness. This gets exemplified through Mary’s transformation. When Mary confronts Remmick and the vampires, she gives them the benefit of the doubt and listens to their music. This leads to a vulnerable moment between the vampires and Mary, which aids Remmick’s attempts to lure her in. Remmick tries manipulating Mary by stating, “you came out here for fellowship and love” ( Sinners, 2025 ). Here Remmick tries to manipulate Mary, who is a white passing biracial woman, by appealing to her whiteness to give her a false sense of community. Knowing how isolated Mary feels within the Black community, Remmick uses his whiteness to convince her to assimilate with the vampires. However, when Mary refuses, Remmick decides to turn her into a vampire by force, thus continuing to show the facade of his so-called community.

The themes of assimilation are further shown through Stack’s confrontation with Smoke. After turning, Stack attempts to lure Smoke in by asserting, “we was never gonna be free. We’ve been running around any way looking for freedom, you know damn well we was never gonna find it. Until this! This is the way!” ( Sinners, 2025 ). These lines highlight how deep Stack has gone into assimilation. To him, becoming a vampire is the freedom him and Smoke were looking for the whole time. Why try to liberate yourself from the horrors of Jim Crow when you can assimilate and become one with the vampires? Why keep fighting when you can fit into the melting pot of vampires where everyone is supposedly equal? This is the easy path, this the only path, at least in Stack’s eyes. Through all this, Remmick has successfully orchestrated a community through the melting pot mindset in order to give a false sense of companionship and security to his victims. This is their way out of Jim Crow, slavery, and the Klan. This is the only way to freedom, even if it’s under the whiteness. Thankfully, this false sense of community doesn’t last long because Smoke kills Remmick by the stake, taking him and his vampires out. Through this action, Smoke breaks the cycle of assimilation, cultural appropriation, and violence against Black bodies. With all this in mind, we must also discuss whiteness and its connections to capitalism.

Section #3: Whiteness And Capitalism

A huge theme in Sinners is the presence of capitalism, specifically how it relates to white supremacy. Throughout the film, both Smoke and Stack fall into the depths of capitalism through bribery, negotiating with white people, and literal blood. They start off wanting to buy Clarksdale’s Klu Klux Klan leader Hogwood’s sawmill to turn it into a juke joint. Right off the bat, Hogwood acts microaggressive towards the twins by referring to them as “boys”. Both of the twins respond differently with Smoke threatening to use his gun on Hogwood and Stack playfully asserting that they’re grown men with money. From the beginning we can see the difference in how the twins approach the system of capitalism. Smoke is more cautious and focused on business while Stack is willing to take anything he can get, which foreshadows both their fates later in the film.

The theme of capitalism continues to shine in Sinners through Annie’s rejection of Smoke’s money. For context, Smoke comes over to Annie’s place to mourn the death of his father and to invite her to the juke joint as a cook. At one point Annie refuses Smoke’s money by stating, “your money come with blood”, though in response Smokes states, “all money come with blood” ( Sinners, 2025 ). These lines highlight Annie’s rejection of capitalism because she understands the violent nature behind the system. Gaining money in a capitalistic system requires some form of violence and exploitation to maintain status and power. However, Smoke sees this refusal as ignorant and not reasonable suspicion.

By the end of the film, we see a shift in Smoke’s character once Hogwood and his Klan come to the sawmill the next day in hopes of killing more Black people. Fortunately, the Klan’s efforts failed as Smoke set up traps around the sawmill and took them out one by one. Through this action we see Smoke’s character development as he not only protects his community, but also rejects capitalism by refusing to negotiate with Hogwood and his money, instead reuniting with Annie and their baby.

On the flip side, Stack’s arc showcases the themes of capitalism in a more tragic light. Both Smoke and Stack care a lot about gaining profit from the juke joint, however Smoke is much more cautious than Stack. Throughout the film, Stack is shown to be more carefree and willing to accept anything for the price of community and wealth. Additionally, it was his idea for the twins to buy the sawmill in the first place, despite a literal Klan member selling it. Stack’s actions highlight the blood that comes from capitalism, the compromises that lead to more harm towards marginalized communities—in this case the Black community. When Stack turns into a vampire by Mary, the horrors of capitalism really begin to show up.

Before everything went down, Mary believed she could help the twins’ business by seeing what Remmick and the vampires had to offer. While she got the money, it cost her her life as she got turned into one of them. When she returns with the money, she manages to lure Stack into sexual intercourse before turning him into one as well. Here we can see that capitalism can only do so much for the Black community because there is always a cost and there is always some form of requirement to give into whiteness. Stack lets his guard down and gives into Mary because of the money and because of his relationship to Mary. In a sense, he chooses to give into whiteness since it offered him some money, but at what cost?

Conclusion

Overall, Sinners is a film with many themes with whiteness being a huge factor that bridges the gap between all themes. The film showcases the downsides of assimilation and capitalism along with how whiteness influences the mindsets of white people.

Sources & Notes

Coogler, R. ( Director ). ( 2025 ). Sinners [ Film ]. Warner Brothers

No AI was used to write this piece.