True Crime Today

Chapter 26: The Gunshot Residue Test — What Did the Evidence Really Reveal?

True Crime TodayByValerie Harvey@investigativejournalist

The gun had been fired.

Daniel Akers was dead.

And investigators had a question they hoped forensic science might help answer:

Who had been holding the weapon when it discharged?

The prosecution believed Lacy Jolee Boles had shot her husband and then attempted to make the death look like suicide.

The defense maintained that Daniel had been holding the gun and that Lacy had grabbed his arm in an effort to stop him.

Now the jury was hearing about a scientific test that might have helped distinguish between those explanations.

Gunshot residue.

But there was a problem.

Only Daniel's hands had been preserved for testing.

Lacy's had not.

1. What Is Gunshot Residue?

Gunshot residue, commonly called GSR, consists of microscopic particles that can be released when a firearm is discharged.

Depending on the circumstances, these particles may be deposited on a person's hands, clothing, or nearby surfaces.

A forensic laboratory can examine samples for particles associated with firearm discharge.

But GSR testing has limitations.

Finding residue on someone's hands does not automatically prove that person fired the weapon.

A person standing close to a firearm when it is discharged may also acquire particles.

And failing to find residue does not necessarily prove that someone never handled or fired a gun.

Time, washing, movement, and environmental conditions can affect whether residue remains detectable.

That meant the jury needed to understand not only what the test could reveal, but also what it could not.

2. Why Daniel's Hands Were Preserved

During testimony, investigator Thomas Ogden acknowledged that Daniel's hands had been preserved for gunshot-residue testing.

The defense questioned him about the reason for doing so.

Brian Steel suggested that the results could be important.

If Daniel had fired the weapon, residue might have been present on his hands.

If he had not, the absence of residue might have been another detail for the jury to consider.

But there was an important complication.

Even if Daniel had residue on his hands, that would not conclusively establish that he pulled the trigger.

He could have acquired particles simply by being close to the gun when it fired.

Ogden acknowledged that possibility.

When asked whether he knew the test results, he said he did not.

He believed testing had been performed, but he could not provide the result.

That left a major question unanswered in the testimony reported so far.

What did the laboratory actually find on Daniel's hands?

3. Why Was Lacy Never Tested?

The defense then turned to Lacy.

If prosecutors believed she had fired the weapon, wouldn't testing her hands have been useful?

Steel questioned Ogden about whether investigators had collected gunshot-residue samples from Lacy at the scene.

They had not.

He also confirmed that she was not tested at the hospital.

The investigator acknowledged that someone who had fired a gun would generally be expected to have residue on their person, although it would not be guaranteed.

But there was another consideration.

Lacy had washed her hands.

Washing can remove or reduce gunshot residue, making a later test less useful.

The prosecution could argue that testing her after she had washed would not necessarily have produced meaningful results.

The defense could respond that investigators had allowed an opportunity for potentially useful evidence to disappear.

Neither argument changed the basic fact:

There was no GSR test result from Lacy's hands.

4. The Defense's Missing-Evidence Argument

Steel's questioning went beyond gunshot residue.

He challenged the investigator about several items that had not been collected or preserved.

Among them:

Lacy's clothing from the night of the shooting.

Photographs documenting her appearance when she left the house.

A recording of her initial explanation at the hospital.

Additional testing that might have clarified the handling of the firearm.

The defense argued that Lacy's clothing could have helped determine whether she had fallen onto Daniel during the struggle she described.

If her account was accurate, the garments might have contained blood-transfer evidence consistent with her explanation.

But investigators had not collected them.

Ogden acknowledged that the clothing was not preserved by his team.

Steel emphasized that the opportunity to examine those garments had been lost.

The prosecution still had to prove its case, but the defense wanted jurors to consider whether the investigation had failed to preserve evidence that could have supported an alternative explanation.

5. Could DNA Have Answered the Question?

The firearm itself presented another possible avenue of investigation.

DNA testing can sometimes identify biological material left on an object.

A firearm may contain DNA from someone who handled it.

But DNA on a gun does not necessarily establish who fired it.

A person might touch a weapon without discharging it.

Another person's biological material might be transferred indirectly.

And a firearm can be handled by multiple people over time.

The defense questioned whether investigators had pursued DNA testing of the weapon, including areas such as the trigger.

The testimony raised questions about what testing had been requested and what results might be available.

The jury would need to hear from the appropriate forensic witnesses before concluding.

The gun might contain valuable information.

But no one should assume that a DNA result, by itself, would identify the shooter.

6. The Left-Hand Question

There was another detail that made the firearm evidence especially important.

Lacy had described Daniel holding the gun in his left hand.

Yet Daniel was described as right-handed.

The prosecution had already questioned the position of the weapon when investigators found him.

The defense wanted jurors to consider whether Daniel could have been holding it as Lacy described.

Steel questioned the investigator about whether he had looked for photographs showing Daniel using his left hand.

Ogden indicated that he had not.

That left another unanswered question.

Was Daniel capable of comfortably holding the gun in his left hand?

The prosecution could argue that the weapon's position was part of a staged scene.

The defense could argue that the position was consistent with the struggle Lacy described.

Without additional evidence, neither interpretation could be treated as fact.

7. The Difference Between Suspicion and Proof

The GSR testimony exposed an important distinction in the case.

There were things investigators believed were suspicious.

There were things Lacy said had happened.

And there were scientific tests that might help determine whether either account was consistent with the physical evidence.

But suspicion was not proof.

The prosecution needed to establish beyond a reasonable doubt that Lacy intentionally caused Daniel's death.

The defense did not have to prove that Daniel died by suicide.

It only needed to show that the prosecution's evidence failed to eliminate reasonable doubt.

That distinction would become increasingly important as the trial continued.

8. The Laboratory Results Still Matter

By the end of the testimony, the jury had heard that Daniel's hands were preserved for GSR testing.

But the investigator could not tell jurors what the laboratory found.

Lacy had not been tested.

The defense had identified missing evidence and questioned whether investigators had pursued every available forensic avenue.

The prosecution still had its theory of an intentional shooting.

And the defense still had its explanation of an accidental discharge during an attempted suicide intervention.

The laboratory evidence could become an important piece of the puzzle.

But until the results were introduced and explained by qualified witnesses, the jury could not know what they meant.

The question was no longer simply whether gunshot residue existed.

It was whether the evidence could reliably connect either person to the fatal shot.

And somewhere in the case file was a laboratory result that might help answer part of that question.

End of Chapter 26

Accuracy note: The November 13 testimony established that Daniel's hands had been preserved for GSR testing, but investigator Ogden did not know the results. Lacy was not tested. This chapter does not invent a laboratory finding or claim that GSR identifies the shooter conclusively. ScribeHawk

Next chapter: Chapter 27 — The Digital Evidence: Deleted Messages, Phone Records, and What Investigators Could Recover.

Sources & Notes

Court TV Live Updates -- Lacy J. Boles

AI helped edit this piece. The author checked the facts and was the final editor.